(New York, NY) Cardholders consider many factors when applying for a new credit card, with those offering no annual fees and attractive rewards structures being the most influential. Auriemma Group’s latest issue of Cardbeat US confirms that offering compelling rewards significantly impacts cardholder decisions, with a clear preference for flat cashback structures over tiered options. The simplicity and predictability of flat cashback resonates strongly with today’s applicants.

When presented with two rewards card structures of roughly equal cashback value, 48% of credit cardholders prefer the flat cashback structure, while 43% lean toward the tiered structure. Although this difference may seem modest, it widens significantly when it comes to application likelihood. 70% of cardholders say they are likely to apply for a flat cashback card, compared to 58% who would apply for a tiered rewards card, if offered by a trusted issuer. These findings highlight the competitive edge of straightforward earning structures.

Cardholders also have high expectations of their credit cards, often looking for value that goes beyond standard offerings. Auriemma’s research found that while a 2.5% flat cashback rate is not common and typically comes with various conditions, many cardholders perceive this level of return as being in line with today’s industry standards. This expectation underscores the challenge for issuers to balance generous rewards with sustainable program structures, especially as preferences vary by demographic.

For instance, issuers aiming to attract Gen Z may find that tiered rewards structures hold unique appeal. This cohort shows a slight preference for tiered rewards, suggesting they may appreciate the potential for optimized earnings that this model offers. By aligning rewards with Gen Z’s preferences, issuers may improve acquisition among younger cardholders.

“While there are reasons to gravitate toward one rewards product over another, flat rewards require little work and mental math on the part of the cardholder,” says Jaclyn Holmes, Director of Research at Auriemma Group. “This makes it the smart option for those who don’t want to give their credit cards much thought, enabling more seamless and stress-free spending experiences.”

Flat rewards structures also hold a distinct advantage in day-to-day usage, with 46% of rewards cardholders reporting that their most frequently used card offers flat cashback. This shows that ease and versatility may make flat cashback cards the popular choice across spending categories, contributing to top-of-wallet status.

Flat cashback cards provide an accessible, simple way to earn, appealing to mass consumers and driving spending across various merchants. Issuers may find that a straightforward rewards model fosters ongoing card usage, as cardholders don’t need to track changing categories to maximize their rewards.

“Flat rewards offer a win-win for both cardholders and issuers,” says Holmes. “Cardholders can enjoy the effortlessness of earning, while issuers benefit from increased acquisition and engagement. As the credit card landscape evolves, prioritizing simplicity in rewards can be a powerful differentiator.”

Survey Methodology

Cardbeat US

This Auriemma Group study was conducted online within the US by an independent field service provider on behalf of Auriemma Group (Auriemma) in September 2024 among 801 adult credit cardholders. The number of interviews completed for both is sufficient to allow for statistical significance testing among sub-groups at the 95% confidence level ±5%, unless otherwise noted. The purpose of the research was not disclosed, nor did respondents know the criteria for qualifying.

(New York, NY) Credit card reward marketplaces such as American Express Membership Rewards, Chase Ultimate Rewards, and Capital One Shopping are becoming a core feature for many credit cardholders. According to Auriemma Group’s latest Cardbeat US report, three-in-five credit cardholders have access to a rewards redemption marketplace, and nearly three-quarters redeem through them for travel bookings, merchandise, gift cards, and more. This method of redemption is even more popular among co-brand credit cardholders, presenting brands with a valuable opportunity to reach a broad audience through these rewards marketplaces.

Although credit cardholders have a variety of available redemption options, the research revealed that the majority redeem their points for the same type of reward every time (86%) and prefer to redeem in one specific category (71%). Most cardholders report saving their points or miles until they have enough for a large redemption.

“Cardholders view their credit card rewards as a means to an aspirational purchase” says Jaclyn Holmes, Director of Research at Auriemma Group. “Cardholders have become accustomed to having a variety of redemption choices and increasingly expect that their favored brands will be available wherever they shop.”

Cardholders are evenly split whether they want to redeem their rewards while shopping with a merchant or through their credit card issuer’s rewards marketplace. Over half believe credit card points are worth the same no matter how they’re redeemed, meaning access and availability largely drive redemption choices.

“While some cardholders passively earn and redeem the rewards they earn, others are more strategic than ever—not just in how they earn rewards, but in how they maximize their value through thoughtful redemption,” says Holmes. “This level of savvy doesn’t just influence their choice of card—it defines their experience with it, driving long-term loyalty and satisfaction.”

Rewards marketplaces are becoming a key driver of card usage as well, with 57% saying their rewards marketplace encourages them to spend more on the associated card. While cashback continues to be the category most redeemed, two-in-five marketplace users commonly redeem for T&E purchases.

As the landscape of rewards redemption continues to evolve, credit card issuers looking to enhance their marketplaces must ensure they are meeting the needs of their diverse cardholder base. The challenge will be to continue providing value and convenience in a way that keeps cardholders engaged and satisfied.

Auriemma Group’s research and partnerships teams are well-equipped to help issuers strategically enhance their card’s value proposition and optimize their rewards marketplace offerings. With deep industry insights and a collaborative approach, Auriemma Group provides the expertise needed to tailor rewards programs that align with cardholder preferences and drive long-term loyalty.

Survey Methodology

Cardbeat US

This Auriemma Group study was conducted online within the US by an independent field service provider on behalf of Auriemma Group (Auriemma) in June 2024 among 800 adult credit cardholders. The number of interviews completed for both is sufficient to allow for statistical significance testing among sub-groups at the 95% confidence level ±5%, unless otherwise noted. The purpose of the research was not disclosed, nor did respondents know the criteria for qualifying.

(London, UK) COVID-19 has brought about many changes in consumer behaviour and issuer offerings. Auriemma Group’s 2020 Cardbeat UK Trend Report identified four areas where shifts were most prominent, highlighting the impact that the pandemic has had on the payment’s ecosystem for both financial institutions and cardholders alike.

1. New card acquisition, spend amounts and card usage have declined.

Cardholders were less engaged with their existing products and fewer sought new products compared to prior years. According to Auriemma’s research, new card acquisition dropped nearly 50%, with only 10% of UK credit cardholders in Q4-20 saying they acquired a new credit card in the past 18 months, down from 18% the same time the year prior.

“Consumers and issuers kept focus on current offerings,” says Jaclyn Holmes, Director at Auriemma Group. “During this period, issuers recognized their efforts were best spent building meaningful and productive engagement with their existing customers. For cardholders, it was critical that they got the most out of their existing products and kept on top of the various solutions that were being presented to them.”

Cardholder spend across payment methods declined from Q4-19 to Q4-20, coinciding with a drop in usage among heavy top of wallet card users. By the end of 2020, UK cardholders reported £854 in average monthly spend, down from £988 the year prior. Meanwhile, the proportion of cardholders who use their most frequently used card 20+ times in a typical month decreased over the same period (30% vs. 22%).

2. Types of rewards cards held shifted away from T&E and towards day-to-day rewards.

The impact of travel restrictions and stay-at-home guidance was felt most prominently in the T&E space. Over 2020, the types of rewards cards held shifted to align with new consumer spend patterns due to COVID-19. Ownership of supermarket co-brand (from 21% in July 2020 to 28% by November) and cash back cards (23% to 27%) rose, as co-branded airline (19% to 9%) and hotel card (5% to 2%) ownership trended down.

“While rewards card ownership shifted towards the end of 2020, and travel naturally became a lesser focus given the obvious limitations, our research found that most T&E cardholders still enjoy earning travel rewards” says Holmes. “These cardholders currently prefer redeeming their rewards for non-travel benefits, but we anticipate travel-centric redemption will bounce back as travel becomes more routine.”

Auriemma recently covered COVID-19’s impact on travel and consumer loyalty in-depth here.

3. Payment holidays became a commonplace issuer-provided relief option.

COVID-19 impacted some cardholders earning potential, leading issuers to develop payment accommodations, including payment holidays, for those unable to make their payments. Despite being a new concept to many, credit card payment holidays had strong consumer awareness by Q4-20 (94% aware), and nearly one-quarter of those offered the option took it.

Future interest was rather low (17%), signalling that the accommodation–which was intended to be a temporary, short-term solution–likely will not be missed post-pandemic. In fact, 58% of cardholders were ambivalent or would not be disappointed if payment holidays were no longer an option in the future.

“We’ve passed the March 31st deadline for cardholders to enrol in payment holidays, so issuers are now preparing for a possible increase in delinquency volume. Most cardholders aren’t expecting to rely on a future payment holiday, but there will be a group who aren’t able to jump back into their payments and will seek alternative accommodations to help make ends meet,” says Holmes.

The government has already shared guidance for such a program. Breathing Space, enacted May 4th of this year, provides a 60-day freezes on interest, fees and enforcement for people in problem debt. The program is expected to bring in £400 million in extra repayments in the first year, ultimately extending upon the improvements made with persistent debt figures throughout 2020.

Auriemma covered payment holidays and Breathing Space in greater detail here.

4. Reduced spend and focus on paying down balances led to fewer in persistent debt.

While shifting finances were a hallmark of COVID-19, reductions in spend and access to payment accommodations led some to improve their financial positions. Auriemma found that the number of cardholders in persistent debt decreased from 7% in Q4-19 to 3% by Q4-20, likely because cardholders were able to focus on paying down their balances without compounding interest slowing them down.

“COVID-19 had the potential to worsen persistent debt, but a combination of cardholder thriftiness and payment accommodations created an environment where consumers could improve their financial standing instead,” says Holmes. “However, as payment holidays come to an end and spend levels return to pre-pandemic levels, we’ll see if this change, along with the others that emerged in the shadow of COVID-19, is long-lasting or temporary.”

Survey Methodology

Cardbeat UK

This Auriemma Group study was conducted online within the UK by an independent field service provider on behalf of Auriemma in November 2020, among 845 adult credit cardholders. The number of interviews completed is sufficient to allow for statistical significance testing between sub-groups at the 95% confidence level ± 5%, unless otherwise noted. The purpose of the research was not disclosed nor did the respondents know the criteria for qualification. The average interview length was 21 minutes.

About Auriemma Group

For more than 30 years, Auriemma’s mission has been to empower clients with authoritative data and actionable insights. Our team comprises recognised experts in four primary areas: operational effectiveness, consumer research, co-brand partnerships, and corporate finance. Our business intelligence and advisory services give clients access to the data, expertise and tools they need to navigate an increasingly complex environment and maximise their performance. Auriemma serves the consumer financial services ecosystem from our offices in London and New York City. For more information, call Jaclyn Holmes at +44 (0) 207 629 0075.

© Copyright - Auriemma Group